Originally Posted by cs3
maybe my sarcasm detector is broken, but uhhh.... You're joking right?
If you don't snappitty snap snap snapoff Goldy the second that trade is sent I dont know what to tell you.
I literally opened this thread to post about how amazing Judge is and what a monster he appears to have become, but cmon man, if you can turn a last round pick/waiver pickup into a perrenial 1st rounder, you do it no questions asked.
edit - that said, Judge is ridiculous! Holy bombs batman!
This is the league I've posted about where crazy trades center on keeper eligibility
Last year keeper-eligible Giolito and stuff got non-k Kris Bryant and stuff.
I picked up Judge in 2015 and kept him through 2 drafts, and he can be kept basically for free forever.
While Goldschmidt is great, I'd only get him for this year.
I am in 2nd right now though, if there were ever a go-for-it year, it'd be this year, and banners fly forever.
The guy who offered Goldschmidt doesn't even have him yet, he's a serial trade-aholic who wants to know up front if he can flip him to me.