Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread 2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread

05-27-2017 , 06:21 AM
The first team I drafted/posted. It drew a lot of scorn Currently in first place.

Quote:
Originally Posted by mrbaseball
1. Blackmon OF
2. Scherzer SP
3. Villar 2B/3B/SS
4. Lester SP
5. Hendricks SP
6. Abreu 1B
7. Colome RP (8 RPs already gone by this point)
8. Herrara RP
9. Quintana SP
10. Kemp OF
11. Eaton OF
12. Watson RP
13. Nunez SS/3B
14. Mauerer RP
15. Fowler OF
16. Gattis C
17. Miller 1B/SS
18. Beltran OF
19. Kiermaier OF
20. Walker 2B
21. Brach RP
22. Gomez RP
23. Hudson RP
Quote:
You're ****ed
Quote:
Hitter over scherzer, anyone over Blackmon, chapman or Jensen over Lester, Watson isn't the official closer yet, and ya Hendricks in the 5th is unforgivable
Yeah Blackmon HUGE mistake In this seasons pitching landscape Scherzer/Lester/Hendricks/Watson all positives.

Quote:
Holy **** this team is bad, would be shocked if you finished top 6.

Hendricks in the 5th is mind numbingly bad and I'm assuming you picked Blackmon over Harper or Rizzo which is incredibly bad as well.

You are going to finish bottom 3 in homers and RBI
Team is top 3 in all offensive cats except HR (7 points) which is middle of pack.

It is still very early but things are starting to take shape. Especially in roto. But my point is managing is much more important than drafting. A good portion of the drafted team (all of the last 10 picks) is already gone and replaced.

DL - Eaton
drops - Mauerer, Fowler, Gattis,, Miller, Beltran, Kiermeier, Walker, Brach, Gomez, Hudson

adds - Hedges, Castro, Shaw, Alther, Suarez, Schebler, Haniger (DL), Devenski, Bradley, Knebel, Hand, Rivero (I move back end (non closer) bullpen pieces often)

Worst category is wins (only 4 points) which I don't worry about since with proper pitching management I will be able to rack more wins in last month when I start streaming for more innings and much of the league will be disinterested and capped at innings.. I always consider wins a catch up category.

My 4 teams are currently 1st, 1st, 1st and 6th. All drafted with a similar drafting strategy. The 6th place team has an uphill battle but isn't buried anywhere. It has suffered the most injury issues which is why it is underperforming.

Once again the point is that good active management and waiver wire awareness greatly trumps whatever happened in the draft as long as your first few picks don't totally **** the bed. I still think finding/getting pitching that doesn't kill you is the key to success. Everybody hits! All of my leagues still have reasonably decent hitters still sitting on the wire that I would be comfortable plugging in if need be. That is not the case with SPs but there are always a few quality non closer RPs to be had.
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 08:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mrbaseball
The first team I drafted/posted. It drew a lot of scorn Currently in first place.







Yeah Blackmon HUGE mistake In this seasons pitching landscape Scherzer/Lester/Hendricks/Watson all positives.



Team is top 3 in all offensive cats except HR (7 points) which is middle of pack.

It is still very early but things are starting to take shape. Especially in roto. But my point is managing is much more important than drafting. A good portion of the drafted team (all of the last 10 picks) is already gone and replaced.

DL - Eaton
drops - Mauerer, Fowler, Gattis,, Miller, Beltran, Kiermeier, Walker, Brach, Gomez, Hudson

adds - Hedges, Castro, Shaw, Alther, Suarez, Schebler, Haniger (DL), Devenski, Bradley, Knebel, Hand, Rivero (I move back end (non closer) bullpen pieces often)

Worst category is wins (only 4 points) which I don't worry about since with proper pitching management I will be able to rack more wins in last month when I start streaming for more innings and much of the league will be disinterested and capped at innings.. I always consider wins a catch up category.

My 4 teams are currently 1st, 1st, 1st and 6th. All drafted with a similar drafting strategy. The 6th place team has an uphill battle but isn't buried anywhere. It has suffered the most injury issues which is why it is underperforming.

Once again the point is that good active management and waiver wire awareness greatly trumps whatever happened in the draft as long as your first few picks don't totally **** the bed. I still think finding/getting pitching that doesn't kill you is the key to success. Everybody hits! All of my leagues still have reasonably decent hitters still sitting on the wire that I would be comfortable plugging in if need be. That is not the case with SPs but there are always a few quality non closer RPs to be had.
ok way to go

sick barg

were all super jealous
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 09:02 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by imjosh
Roto format catcher rankings ROS

1. Avila

LARGE GAP

2. Sanchez
3. Posey

LARGE GAP

4. Lucroy
5. Sal. Pereze

6-100. Empty Roster slot
there is a serious lack of grandal on this list
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 10:22 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mrbaseball
The first team I drafted/posted. It drew a lot of scorn Currently in first place.







Yeah Blackmon HUGE mistake In this seasons pitching landscape Scherzer/Lester/Hendricks/Watson all positives.



Team is top 3 in all offensive cats except HR (7 points) which is middle of pack.

It is still very early but things are starting to take shape. Especially in roto. But my point is managing is much more important than drafting. A good portion of the drafted team (all of the last 10 picks) is already gone and replaced.

DL - Eaton
drops - Mauerer, Fowler, Gattis,, Miller, Beltran, Kiermeier, Walker, Brach, Gomez, Hudson

adds - Hedges, Castro, Shaw, Alther, Suarez, Schebler, Haniger (DL), Devenski, Bradley, Knebel, Hand, Rivero (I move back end (non closer) bullpen pieces often)

Worst category is wins (only 4 points) which I don't worry about since with proper pitching management I will be able to rack more wins in last month when I start streaming for more innings and much of the league will be disinterested and capped at innings.. I always consider wins a catch up category.

My 4 teams are currently 1st, 1st, 1st and 6th. All drafted with a similar drafting strategy. The 6th place team has an uphill battle but isn't buried anywhere. It has suffered the most injury issues which is why it is underperforming.

Once again the point is that good active management and waiver wire awareness greatly trumps whatever happened in the draft as long as your first few picks don't totally **** the bed. I still think finding/getting pitching that doesn't kill you is the key to success. Everybody hits! All of my leagues still have reasonably decent hitters still sitting on the wire that I would be comfortable plugging in if need be. That is not the case with SPs but there are always a few quality non closer RPs to be had.
Yes, managing and waivers does trump drafting, but that doesn't mean you put yourself in a massive hole to begin the season and rely on getting almost all the waiver guys that hit. Because that usually doesn't happen in competitive leagues.

It's also may, I'm still,incredibly confident your offense will not last
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 10:51 AM
Blackman and Hendricks picks weren't great (regardless of if they worked out or not). Honestly everything else is fine but I wouldn't have taken so many pitchers that early...
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 10:54 AM
Who should I drop to pick up kahnle (who for some reason was dropped) in a 5x5 roto

Castellanos, josh Harrison, Cesar, piscottY

Have good replacements(or existing starters) for all
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 10:57 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GTBMuckface
there is a serious lack of grandal on this list
Grandal is great.

Also lol at Avila > Posey and Sanchez

Posey has 7hrs and only 11 rbis, which likely means he's had horrific cluster luck which will regress. I like Avila a lot, but come on
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 10:57 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mgv1208
Who should I drop to pick up kahnle (who for some reason was dropped) in a 5x5 roto

Castellanos, josh Harrison, Cesar, piscottY

Have good replacements(or existing starters) for all
I just cut Castellanos to pick up Harrison
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 11:45 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mgv1208
Who should I drop to pick up kahnle (who for some reason was dropped) in a 5x5 roto

Castellanos, josh Harrison, Cesar, piscottY

Have good replacements(or existing starters) for all
Not sure who you should drop but Kahnle is a great speculative shot. If/when Robertson gets traded Kahnle will be the closer unless Jones gets back from DL and even then Jones has to be 100%. Kahnle consistently brings some 99+ heat and even without the job gets about 2K's per inning with great ratios. I have 2 shares and he is available in my other leagues and I have owned him at some point on all of my teams. If trade news get serious I will grab him in the others.
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 11:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by imjosh
Roto format catcher rankings ROS

1. Avila

LARGE GAP

2. Sanchez
3. Posey

LARGE GAP

4. Lucroy
5. Sal. Pereze

6-100. Empty Roster slot
Quote:
Originally Posted by mgv1208
Grandal is great.

Also lol at Avila > Posey and Sanchez

Posey has 7hrs and only 11 rbis, which likely means he's had horrific cluster luck which will regress. I like Avila a lot, but come on
I love Avila and all, but def not over Sanchez/Posey. He's a backup C, I only advocate and post on here when he's getting regular playtime, which is now. When McCann is back, you can't roster Avila, so it doesnt matter how well he hits.

Also, Kinsler to DL
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 01:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DonkOneMore
I love Avila and all, but def not over Sanchez/Posey. He's a backup C, I only advocate and post on here when he's getting regular playtime, which is now. When McCann is back, you can't roster Avila, so it doesnt matter how well he hits.

Also, Kinsler to DL
I think it was a joke about Avila
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 01:13 PM
active management is a supplement to good drafting. it's not mutually exclusive
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 01:15 PM
And yes Blackmon was a huge mistake considering you passed on Harper
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 01:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DonkOneMore
Unconvinced on Lomo, but def other 2. Also Avila with another HR tonight...

edit: Guess unconvinced is bad wording, think he's a solid pickup, but injury prone (and likely running hot), and so many good 1B being picked up clogging Util's, just so little room
The 1b clogging is my chief issue with him

In April he already had a > 20% HR/FB but in May he's at a FB/GB of .58, hard hit up to 49% soft hit down to 9. How sustainable? Idk, if the ratio shifts back it obviously hurts but I tend to think the power is real. I don't know what changes he made to his approach but it does seem one was made
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 01:28 PM
The Avila post was a joke, but I am enjoying the production. In a Roto format it's arguable that a guy like Avila is better than most other catchers even if he doesn't have the volume that the other middle and low-tier guys get. One of the things you can really get crushed at in Roto is having a catcher who puts up minimal counting stats while tanking your AVG/OBP. I think i'd rather have a catcher than has an OBP of 0.350 and gets 2R, 2RBI, and 1HR a week than a catcher than has an OBP of 0.300 and gets 3R, 3RBI, and 1HR a week. The impact is magnified or minimized based on how many hitters you start though.
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 01:31 PM
Bour is actually probably the one I believe in the least, but I think at the moment he has the most resale value. His splits are just littered with red flags that go beyond accounting for him running hot right now

Edit: that being said it's interesting that while he's striking out more against lefties he's also hitting the ball harder against them than RHP

Edit2: man just cannot get a read on this guy
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 02:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GTBMuckface
ok way to go

sick barg

were all super jealous
This
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 04:22 PM
"For everyone who ****-talked my getting all-in by five-betting vs AA preflop, I hit my set on the flop, so I was right!"
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 05:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by imjosh
The Avila post was a joke, but I am enjoying the production. In a Roto format it's arguable that a guy like Avila is better than most other catchers even if he doesn't have the volume that the other middle and low-tier guys get. One of the things you can really get crushed at in Roto is having a catcher who puts up minimal counting stats while tanking your AVG/OBP. I think i'd rather have a catcher than has an OBP of 0.350 and gets 2R, 2RBI, and 1HR a week than a catcher than has an OBP of 0.300 and gets 3R, 3RBI, and 1HR a week. The impact is magnified or minimized based on how many hitters you start though.
Haha I'm dumb
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 07:25 PM
Taillon starting rehab assignment tomorrow in AA, if he's available pick up ASAP
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 08:48 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gary Wise
"For everyone who ****-talked my getting all-in by five-betting vs AA preflop, I hit my set on the flop, so I was right!"
Lmao so true,

I'll just wait for him to post his team at the end of September
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 09:13 PM
Salazar could be heading to the bullpen
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-27-2017 , 09:56 PM
good god
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 02:51 AM
Lucroy sucks huh
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 04:10 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hurp Durpington
active management is a supplement to good drafting. it's not mutually exclusive
I have twelve pitchers and I drafted three of them

Verlander Cole tanaka wood berrios bush bud Norris brach Reed glover e rod Paxton

Got lucky as **** with conforto and Bellinger and Haniger to some extent too. Just dropped Haniger for G polanco. 10 team so pretty shallow but still. Pretty sure my draft was horrible but got so lucky on Ww that I'm in first


Tanaka was a buy super low for Hamilton which might be horrible idk but Hamilton was useless to me as I have goldy and trea turner etc and never started him in 6 cat plus pollock coming back soon

Last edited by mutigers; 05-28-2017 at 04:16 AM. Reason: I
2017 Fantasy Baseball Thread Quote

      
m