Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
How does other unknown player's cards affect your outs? How does other unknown player's cards affect your outs?

06-13-2015 , 05:56 PM
Cards folded realy have some "blocker effect" even though a realy light.

That is because small cards got preflop fold more often than high card. Imagine you play FR table, sitting on SB and everybody folded to you. 10 cards were folded, the cards are unknown but cannot be considered random. Because aces are played more often than small cards.
Previous folds make aces on flop, turn, river more likely and the same your range and range of the BB are stronger - both of you have A,K,Q... more often than without previous folds.
There were some simulations made, Nash ranges recalculated with regard to folded cards. Some diferences found, but not so big to care about it.
How does other unknown player's cards affect your outs? Quote
06-13-2015 , 07:12 PM
Here's yet another way of saying it:

9-handed game, you've got a spade flush draw on the turn and are heads up against one opponent.

Standard thinking says you have 9 outs from 46 remaining (unseen) cards, and so your odds of hitting on the river are 9/46.

Now, of course if you somehow knew that 6 spades were among the folded (and your heads-up opponent's) cards, your outs drop drastically to only 3, but don't forget you'd also subtract 16 cards from the remaining 46, since there are only 30 cards left in the deck to draw from. Therefore, your odds of hitting on the river are 3/30 (10%). Pretty terrible.

Next, let's make the opposite assumption. If somehow you knew not a single spade was among your opponents' cards, then you would still have the 9 outs, but, remembering to subtract the 16 cards that are no longer in the deck, your odds are 9/30. You're 30% to nail the river. So you have a much greater chance of hitting than conventional flush draw odds suggest.

OP, you're wanting to make theoretical assumptions that some of your outs are dead, therefore your odds have been negatively impacted. The point I'm trying to make is that the opposite hypothetical could also be true, that your odds are positively impacted by folded non-spade cards.

It's equally as likely for your drawing odds to be positively affected by card removal factors as it is for them to be negatively affected. On average, yeah probably a few of your outs WILL be in the muck. But this is why we leave the denominator at 46. We don't reduce it to 30, because every card that we have not seen with our own two eyes must be treated the same. They're all part of the same pool from which the next card will come.
How does other unknown player's cards affect your outs? Quote
06-18-2015 , 05:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by p2ppoker
Thank you for the post, however, I think that only applies when the same number of players exist at the table.

Shouldn't the odds change once the number of hands that are dealt out affect your odds?

Wouldn't the more accurate way to determine draws between 6 - 9 player table, take into account you are drawing to a random deck of 37 cards vs. a random deck of 31 cards (on the flop)?

Maybe I'm just too dumb to understand it lol.
For the purposes of determining probability of getting a particular card, or one of a particular set of cards, there are only two types of cards: Known cards, and unknown cards. If you're trying to complete a flush on the river, you have seen six cards (Your two and four board cards). There are 46 cards you haven't seen. Nine of the 46 unseen cards are of your suit. It matters not one bit to probability where those unseen cards are. You have a probability of 9/46 that the river card will make your flush. If you take 45 of the remaining cards and throw them in the fireplace there is still a 9/46 probability that the remaining card will complete your flush.

In the years I've been posting on gambling forums, this question has come up many times, and it seems to be really difficult for some people. I don't know why. To me it's obvious.
How does other unknown player's cards affect your outs? Quote
06-18-2015 , 05:46 PM
If you're on the button in a 9-handed game and its folded to you and you know the ranges of all the players that have folded thus far, there is definitely going to be some equation/math stuffs you could do to determine how often something like a 2 is folded there if you are holding 22.

For example, since more of their hands should be strong, it is more likely they fold something like 2X over AX, so when holding 22 OTB, it's more likely 2's have been removed than an A.

From a theory point of view, it is technically possible to calculate something like that if you know their ranges. But your specific example, chasing clubs, probably ends up canceling out.

Anyways, none of this is going to be useful and it would be pretty negligible.
How does other unknown player's cards affect your outs? Quote
06-19-2015 , 12:34 PM
06-19-2015 , 12:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by p2ppoker
You can calculate the odds that you are drawing dead though. You don't know for certain whether you are or not.

Wouldn't it be more accurate to rather than assume what was folded is unknown, to assign odds as to what was most likely folded?

For example, if I was dealt 2 clovers, I could calculate what are the odds that my opponent sitting across from me also has 2 clovers, rather than assuming I have no way of knowing.

But I could easily calculate the odds of what it is that all the clovers are dealt out pre flop. That odd would exist in a 9 player game, while it does not exist heads-up.

We are working with probabilities correct? Well, at a 9 handed table, there is a chance you are drawing dead.

The real fallacy is that you cannot know what was folded. I may not know what was folded, but I can calculate the odds that the card folded was a clover as opposed to something else.

For example, what is the average number of clovers that will be dealt out in 18 cards?

So the first clover being dealt out has a 1/4 in chance, and you run it for the 2nd, 3rd, and you run the odds of how many clovers should be dealt out in 18 cards.

It's not entirely unknown, because you can technically know the odds that your out is already gone.

The assumption that it doesn't matter works under the assumption that the card is UNKNOWN, but we can assign odds to what it is, and these odds are not equal.

Let's say for example that I hold 2 clovers, and my opponent sitting across from me folds, without any reads, I can assign odds that my opponent also folded 2 clovers.

True, I don't know if he folded 2 clovers, but I can figure out the odds that he folded 2 clovers.

Edit:
I know I'm probably wrong, I just don't know why I'm wrong, I'll just take it on faith that it's all the same lol.

If you actually do this, you will find that you will get the same answer:


Quote:
Originally Posted by Lego05

You hold a flush draw on the flop in a 6 player game so there's 10 cards the other players hold that you don't know what they are:


First let's do it without considering other players' cards:

You know your cards and the flop .... so that leaves 47 cards and 9 that make you a flush. So 9/47.




Now let's think about the other player's cards:

Now in the 47 remaining cards there are 9 of your suit. That means about 19% of the remaining cards are of your suit. So now let's look at the 10 cards the other players are holding. 19% of 10 is about 1.9 so the other players hold on average 1.9 of the cards that are the suit you need for the flush and 8.1 of them will be of other suits ..... so now we have 7.1/37




9/47 = 7.1/37. It's the same.
How does other unknown player's cards affect your outs? Quote
06-19-2015 , 07:24 PM
I think an easy way to think about it is like in quantum mechanics the percentages you get are an average of the sum over all possibilities.
How does other unknown player's cards affect your outs? Quote
06-19-2015 , 07:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by EC2200
I think an easy way to think about it is like in quantum mechanics the percentages you get are an average of the sum over all possibilities.
Haha nice level.
How does other unknown player's cards affect your outs? Quote
06-19-2015 , 11:43 PM
Hate QM

/end rant
How does other unknown player's cards affect your outs? Quote
06-23-2015 , 08:37 PM
come on 2015
How does other unknown player's cards affect your outs? Quote

      
m