Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
A closed but sharp position in an online Pirc A closed but sharp position in an online Pirc

06-19-2013 , 08:18 PM
Searching for good examples of the Pirc Defence in the FICS database, I've stumbled across the following interesting 15-min game played in 2003 between a 2239 (White) and a 1912 (FICS ratings are inflated but I'm not sure if it applied back then).

As I almost haven't played for 12 years, I didn't rely on my own tactical vision and checked variations with the free Houdini 1.5a , but in such unclear positions engines tend to find repetition draws so the evaluation question remains open, and you're welcome to make analytical comments and train tactical skills - I've spoilered some critical moves, and there are quite a few sacs in variations!

The PGN can be downloaded at ficsgames (end position spoiler alert!), and the replayer is also duplicated at chessvideos (for faster diagram-making).

1. e4 d6 2. d4 Nf6 3. Nc3 g6 4. Nf3 Bg7 5. Be2 O-O 6. O-O Bg4 7. h3 Bxf3 8. Bxf3 Nc6 9. Be3 e5 10. d5 Ne7 11. Be2 Nd7 12. f3 f5 13. a4 f4 14. Bf2 g5 15. Nb5 a6 16. Na3 Ng6 17. c4 a5 (preventing b2-b4, but the knight returns to a comfortable square) 18. Nb5 Rf7 (what a strange plan to place the rook on g7) 19. Qd2 Bf8 20. Rfc1 h5 21. b4 axb4 22. Qxb4 Rg7 23. a5 Nf6 24. Na7 (with a discovered attack on the b7 pawn, 24. c5 = is a calm option) g4!?



What would you play here as White? What comes to mind is Qxb7 or hxg4.

After 25. Qxb7, Black can discover an attack on the queen and x-ray the knight by 25. ... c5, so it doesn't look like a sensible move.

However, White has a good reply:
Spoiler:
26. dxc6!! Rxb7 27. cxb7, and now Black will lose the whole rook for the passed b-pawn and then a piece more trying to deal with the a-pawn. If 27. ... Rb8 28. Nc6 Qc7 29. Nxb8 Qxb8??, trying to lose merely an exchange, then 30. a6! wins the queen for one of the connected passed pawns.
So Black's best option is to chase the bishop off the protection of the knight by 25. ... g3 26. Be1 c5 27. a6 Rxa7 =+(?), getting an extra piece against the passed a-pawn in an unclear position (it looks like Black will slowly but surely untangle the constrained piece setup whilst maneuvering tediously around the a-pawn ).

Another sensible 26th move for White pointed out by the engine is
Spoiler:
26. Bc5(!?) (a positional sac doubling black pawns and clearing the path for the white d-pawn in those variations where the c7 pawn falls) dxc5 27. Nc6, blocking the c7 pawn and thus disabling the kingside rook. White will try to win a piece back for the a-pawn.

Brute force engine analysis (calculating the best ply with a decent depth, making it and calculating the next one, and so on) says that White has a forced draw: 27. ... Qc8 28. a6 Nd7 29. Rcb1 Nb6 30. Bd1 Rf7 31. Ba4 Rf6 32. Bb5 Bd6 33. Na7, and Black has to repeat moves because his queen has to keep an eye on the white one to prevent a6-a7, while 33. ... Qxb7 34. axb7 Rb8 35. Nc6 Rb7 36. Ba6 drops a rook.

But it's known that engines fail in the endgame so the question whether to play 26. Be1, 26. Bc5 or maybe something else remains open
Instead, 25. hxg4 hxg4 was played. Now a good continuation is
Spoiler:
26. a6!? bxa6 27. Nc6 =+. Black will be distracted from the kingside action to exchange this strong outpost and some other pieces to deflect the queenside attack; despite being a pawn down, there will be fewer worries for White than after his actual move opening his king. 25. a6 right away would lead to similar positions.
But in the game there was 26. fxg4?? (this natural move surely doesn't win a pawn, but why is it a grave blunder?!) Nxe4 27. Qxb7?? (the most stubborn line is 27. Qe1 but even then a piece is still lost after
Spoiler:
27. ... Ng3!? 28. Bxg3 fxg3, and it's better to drop the a7 knight because of 29. Nb5 Qh4! 30. Bf3 Rf7 31. Kf1 Rxf3+! 32. Ke2 Rf2+ (32. gxf3 Nf4) with a strong mating attack forcing White to lose material)

Nxf2 28. Nc6 (28. Kxf2 c5) Qh4! 29. Qxa8? (29. Ra2 Re8 30. Bf3 Nxg4 31. Bxg4 Qxg4 32. Qb2 f3 is more stubborn)



Now Black has a couple of ways to win fast. The actual move was
Spoiler:
29. ... Nh3+! (what a fancy knight sac!) 30. gxh3 Qg3+ 31. Kf1 f3 32. Ra2? (32. Bd3 Nf4 33. Rc2 (the second rank has to be controlled) is more stubborn but hopeless too) fxe2+ 33. Kxe2 Rf7 34. Rd2? (34. Qa7 is more stubborn) Qf3+ 35. Ke1 Qf1# 0-1
but an even more effective move is
Spoiler:
29. ... Ne4!! White will now have to lose tons of material to prevent a forced checkmate. E.g. 30. Qa7 Rh7 31. Kf1 Nd2+ 32. Kg1 Qh2+ 33. Kf2 Qg3+ 34. Kg1 Nh4 35. Qf2



Spoiler:
35. ... Qh2+!! (a decoy sac of the whole queen!) 36. Kxh2 Nhf3# 0-1
GL with your chess!

Last edited by coon74; 06-19-2013 at 08:28 PM.
A closed but sharp position in an online Pirc Quote
06-22-2013 , 01:20 AM
This is a deceptive thread title as the position given is a Bayonet King's Indian Defence position, although it came from a Pirc initial move order.

I think it was a strategic error by White to allow Black this attack, with White having played h3 already.

Last edited by Kittens; 06-22-2013 at 01:34 AM.
A closed but sharp position in an online Pirc Quote
06-22-2013 , 01:24 AM
As a general assessment, Black's attack only works if he has the light-squared bishop to break through on h3, after ...g3; h3. White's successfully removed this, so Black's attack should fail (and White will have a winning queen-side attack).

However, white has played h3 voluntarily, a mistake. Black's attack probably will work here. If hxg4, Black will come play hxg4, then come down the h-file (perhaps with Nh5-g3, or ..g3).

It will just be a matter of calculation as to who wins from here, a good computer should be able to see it through.

Last edited by Kittens; 06-22-2013 at 01:32 AM.
A closed but sharp position in an online Pirc Quote

      
m