Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Will Religion survive the 21st century?

08-19-2010 , 12:52 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
This is bull****. What has been explained by science today is very very little of what was attributed to God. Science explains whats happening, but in most cases does not explain why it is happening.

Science gives us the mechanism, that's all. In other words, it gives us the what and how, never the why. This idea that people were attributing the world around us to magic is just a strawman.

If someone was to say right now that plants grow because of God, science would have nothing to say about it. There's more reason to believe in God then ever before.
i dont follow
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-19-2010 , 02:31 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
There is more atheists on this site that claim this then theists.
I know you won't bother trying to dig up evidence to back this up...but i have yet to see any atheist on here claim this.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-19-2010 , 02:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
This is bull****. What has been explained by science today is very very little of what was attributed to God. Science explains whats happening, but in most cases does not explain why it is happening.

Science gives us the mechanism, that's all. In other words, it gives us the what and how, never the why. This idea that people were attributing the world around us to magic is just a strawman.

If someone was to say right now that plants grow because of God, science would have nothing to say about it. There's more reason to believe in God then ever before.
definitely NOT a strawman...how can you even suggest it is based on what we know of ancient cultures beliefs? (and lol at your last sentence)
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-19-2010 , 02:45 AM
i mean, if you want to say there's just as much reason to believe in god as any time in the past, im fine with that. but saying there's more reason is just ridiculous, imo.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-19-2010 , 04:13 AM
It already has the power to move independent research aside and dub it political bias and conspiratorical and make this view mainstream. Over the 21st century we're seeing a shift in conflicts from being purely political towards being in large parts religious. Certain States are passing dictatorial laws because they see certain religions as threat. Theocracies have even managed to change UN charters on free speech, and for that matter the UN's power of diplomacy in modern conflict is just a powerless joke compared to the role it played in the 60s, 70s and 80s.

Sure, there might be a dwindling in numbers in believers in a sparse selection of countries around the world - but religion is increasing in power, not fading away.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-19-2010 , 09:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
This is bull****. What has been explained by science today is very very little of what was attributed to God. Science explains whats happening, but in most cases does not explain why it is happening.

Science gives us the mechanism, that's all. In other words, it gives us the what and how, never the why. This idea that people were attributing the world around us to magic is just a strawman.

If someone was to say right now that plants grow because of God, science would have nothing to say about it. There's more reason to believe in God then ever before.
This logic is flawed. If we understand the what and how, we understand parts. That is more than we understood 2000 years ago when people knew nothing.
Of course we have a lot more gaps to fill, but no one tries to fill them with faith.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-19-2010 , 12:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Concerto
BTW, one thing I expect to not survive the 21st century is this absurdly naive "faith versus science" false dichotomy being pushed by the priests of McScience, "either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists" style.
Weak minds and thinkers continue to fall for this in droves.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-19-2010 , 12:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
Non-religious wars have cause WAY more damage and carnage then religious wars have. If I remember correctly the death toll from religious wars is something like 6-7%, and if you take out Islam then it drops to like 3-4%.
Pilots are no meaner or psychotic than archers.
Machine gunners are not more sadistic than swordsmen.

I'm not going to do the math or history for you, but it does explain your fallacy above.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-19-2010 , 02:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Concerto
The more science explains, the more it leaves unexplained. That is pretty much inherent in the process as we have so far experienced it, and is what we want anyway. The amount of known unknowns (i.e. "gaps") has been increased by science.
An increase in gaps does not imply an increase in the unexplained. If this was geometry you would be confusing area with length.

Consider these two:

1. XOOOOOXOOOOOX
2. XOXOXOXOXOXOX

Is the one with the most O (unexplained) the same as the one with the most X (explained)?

A better visualization would be to consider a graph that goes from somewhat jagged to very jagged. More peaks do not imply less area.

Last edited by tame_deuces; 08-19-2010 at 03:03 PM.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-19-2010 , 04:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by luckyme
Pilots are no meaner or psychotic than archers.
Machine gunners are not more sadistic than swordsmen.

I'm not going to do the math or history for you, but it does explain your fallacy above.
What? I'm not following at all.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-19-2010 , 04:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
What? I'm not following at all.
Lol...I don't think I've ever followed a luckyme post in my whole history of posting on 2+2.

He has a very cryptic style. I'm not sure why but it makes him rather unintelligible.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-19-2010 , 04:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
Non-religious wars have cause WAY more damage and carnage then religious wars have. If I remember correctly the death toll from religious wars is something like 6-7%, and if you take out Islam then it drops to like 3-4%.

So the question should really be, if religion fades away, will society last?
Where did you get your numbers from? This site:

http://users.erols.com/mwhite28/warstatz.htm#RelCon

attributes ~800 million deaths to the religious wars. If thats only 6-7% of the total, that means there have been over 12 billion deaths cause by war. that seems a bit high.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-19-2010 , 05:04 PM
Prediction By 2300, Scientology will be dominant world religion

Reason: Modern fake religions hoard money and power much more efficiently than old fake religions.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-19-2010 , 05:06 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by G1982
Prediction By 2300, Scientology will be dominant world religion

Reason: Modern fake religions hoard money and power much more efficiently than old fake religions.
much more likely that mormonism will be the prominent "Christian" theology in the next century.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-19-2010 , 09:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jibninjas
What? I'm not following at all.
He means modern weapons can kill more people regardless of the intent of the people using them. I think the thing that matters though is that the world's population has risen a ton over the past 200 years and there have been more atheists in charge recently. Of course the main atheist killers (communists) have done most of their slaughter in "peace time" against their own people so I suppose those deaths have to be discounted.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-20-2010 , 02:09 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by random hater
They will be improved on, yes. I forget who but someone wrote an essay on discarding theories of yesterday for theories of today. i.e. each theory is closer than the truth and we only come up with new ones as we find more information.

e.g. in the beginning it made sense that the world was flat.
Then we noticed it was curved as ships would disappear as they sailed away.
Then we thought the world was spherical.
Now we think it's an ellipsoid.
Tomorrow we will have a new theory, but we won't think it is a pyramid or a donut shape. Each time we are much closer than before.

edit: oh yeah asimov wrote it

So, when someone that thought the world was flat was proven wrong, they weren't really wrong, the other guy was closer to the truth? Well, that's one way to make scienetists that supported theories and even some laws that became obsolete as not so bad at all. When Science shutouts beliefs of others that might challenge their belief system, what is that? When it is known that most of sciences belief systems end up looking foolish in time.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-20-2010 , 10:24 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SOBERMARK
So, when someone that thought the world was flat was proven wrong, they weren't really wrong, the other guy was closer to the truth? Well, that's one way to make scienetists that supported theories and even some laws that became obsolete as not so bad at all. When Science shutouts beliefs of others that might challenge their belief system, what is that? When it is known that most of sciences belief systems end up looking foolish in time.
Maybe you should just read the article.

Quote:
Originally Posted by ganstaman
No, it's not known because it's not true. The scientific theories will be refined, but they won't as a whole be thrown out.

http://chem.tufts.edu/AnswersInScien...ityofWrong.htm
We are becoming so accurate that most of science can not be wrong. It may need refinement, but the degree to which it's off is too small to throw up your arms and declare that your whole life is changing.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-21-2010 , 02:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ganstaman
Maybe you should just read the article.



We are becoming so accurate that most of science can not be wrong. It may need refinement, but the degree to which it's off is too small to throw up your arms and declare that your whole life is changing.
Spiritual Beliefs have been with Man since before recorded history. Most if not all these scienctific theories and even some laws go out the window over time. Sometimes it takes a few generations or a few hundred years for the science of the day to go with the wind. The trend over our entire history is with Spirituality. That doesn't mean we abandon science, it just means keeping an open mind as opposed to dogmatic adherance to some theory or law that may be failing is Wise!
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-21-2010 , 05:38 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SOBERMARK
Spiritual Beliefs have been with Man since before recorded history. Most if not all these scienctific theories and even some laws go out the window over time. Sometimes it takes a few generations or a few hundred years for the science of the day to go with the wind. The trend over our entire history is with Spirituality. That doesn't mean we abandon science, it just means keeping an open mind as opposed to dogmatic adherance to some theory or law that may be failing is Wise!
The ability for scientific discoveries to be found wrong is a strength of science, not a weakness. Besides, religious beliefs have not been constant throughout history. Christians and Muslims are prevalent today, but where do you think they were 'before recorded history'?
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-21-2010 , 11:54 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SOBERMARK
Spiritual Beliefs have been with Man since before recorded history. Most if not all these scienctific theories and even some laws go out the window over time. Sometimes it takes a few generations or a few hundred years for the science of the day to go with the wind. The trend over our entire history is with Spirituality. That doesn't mean we abandon science, it just means keeping an open mind as opposed to dogmatic adherance to some theory or law that may be failing is Wise!
So... you didn't read the article?
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-21-2010 , 05:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Funology
The ability for scientific discoveries to be found wrong is a strength of science, not a weakness. Besides, religious beliefs have not been constant throughout history. Christians and Muslims are prevalent today, but where do you think they were 'before recorded history'?


The Christian tradition begin before recorded history with the Aural tradition. Some of this is even obvious in the Bible. You may notice that the book of genesis has a short story at the start, that was a spoken memorized story told around Hebrew Camps long before most people were writing anything. You may not beleive it, but, the Christian Traditions begin at the beginning of time. The Bible has survived for a minimum of thousands of years. The odds and probability is that that will continue.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-21-2010 , 05:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ganstaman
So... you didn't read the article?

Kind of like you didn't read my actual post or respond to it.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-21-2010 , 05:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by random hater
He means modern weapons can kill more people regardless of the intent of the people using them. I think the thing that matters though is that the world's population has risen a ton over the past 200 years and there have been more atheists in charge recently. Of course the main atheist killers (communists) have done most of their slaughter in "peace time" against their own people so I suppose those deaths have to be discounted.
The only way that the standard anti-religion line works about wars is if you count atheism as a religion, then deaths skyrocket beyond imagination.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-21-2010 , 08:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SOBERMARK
Kind of like you didn't read my actual post or respond to it.
Oh no, I read your post. But you didn't respond to my post. Sure, you quoted me and then typed your message below, but what you said did nothing to further the discussion past what I had said. If you had just read the short article, you would have been able to reply appropriately.

You see, that's what happens in forums. If you just go on posting whatever comes to your mind, then this would be a blog. But the idea is that you take in others' ideas and reply to those instead so that a discussion/debate can develop. But you have to first actually listen to what the other people are saying. And read the article that 2 of us, within 8 minutes of your post, recognized as something that would be very educational for you and applies directly to your post.
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote
08-21-2010 , 08:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SOBERMARK
The Christian tradition begin before recorded history with the Aural tradition. Some of this is even obvious in the Bible. You may notice that the book of genesis has a short story at the start, that was a spoken memorized story told around Hebrew Camps long before most people were writing anything. You may not beleive it, but, the Christian Traditions begin at the beginning of time. The Bible has survived for a minimum of thousands of years. The odds and probability is that that will continue.
But you don't really believe that Christianity has not changed in all this time, do you? The aural traditions you're talking about involved Judaism, not Christianity. Even now, there is a plethora of denominations with a multitude of different practices, rituals, and biblical interpretations. Christianity, just like language, culture, and other religions, has evolved over time.

When you say 'Christian traditions' began at the beginning of time, you can't possibly be correct, because there is abundant evidence of ancient Egyptian and Sumerian religions literally thousands of years before the Jews even existed. Unless you are claiming to be a young earth creationist...?
Will Religion survive the 21st century? Quote

      
m