Originally Posted by asdfasdf32
You're reasoning for why we can't have a probability is nonsensical (that doesn't mean your conclusion is flawed).
I didn't say we can't have probability, In the case where people are writing anything but 0 or 100% is where you can't.
To have anything that is 50% or 37%, the other has to happen is what I'm getting at.
So if someone doesn't believe in god or someone does believe in god, writes something in-between, the person is really writing something that they shouldn't be.
edit: Even for people that think there is a chance for anything, writing anything but 0 or 100% is foolish from a statistical standpoint.