Quote:
Originally Posted by DoOrDoNot
You know you're not going to encourage open discussion and dialogue if you just ban-threaten everyone who comes within earshot of quasi-insulting someone.
A mod isn't here to protect feelings, a mod is here to protect the T&C of 2+2 and I'm pretty sure you're allowed to post images as long as they're not completely porn or obscene or whatever.
Personally I think someone would have to be the most sensitive individual in the world to be insulted by that picture, and even if they were insulted, so what? Go to a Christian or Atheist forum to have your fur rubbed the right way, there are both types here. Since when did 2+2 ever even claim to guarantee people weren't going to be offended?
How other people take those pictures is up to them, not you.
If you aren't aware of that you shouldn't be a mod.
Here in RGT we have
some additional rules that go beyond the T&C, placed in a convenient sticky located at the top of the main RGT page. They lay out some of the basic principles that are meant to promote better discussions in this forum. As moderators, we use those rules as a guide to when a post should be deleted or edited. Some of those rules require us to use our own judgement, such as judging whether a post is consistent with the "tone" of a thread, or whether a post is meant to be maliciously insulting or merely a playful jab among friends.
The problem with moderating posts with images in them is that the meaning of an image tends to be more viewer-dependent than the meaning of text. For example, an image that wasn't meant to be insulting can pretty easily and justifiably be taken as such by a member of the group it mocks. This means that the moderator is forced to rely more on his own subjective understanding of an image in deciding how to mod it, which makes it more difficult to present solid reasons as to why it should be deleted if he thinks it should be.
All that being said, I don't think there is anything insuperable about moderating images, and I think our default should definitely be towards allowing things rather than banning them, so I think we should maintain present policy towards posting images. I also think that the image that VP$IP posted in this thread is well within the bounds of mockery that has been allowed in this forum and so shouldn't be deleted.
Finally, this discussion is a derail, so if you have anything further to add, I'll double post this to the
"Random Chat" thread and you can discuss it there.
Last edited by Original Position; 10-19-2011 at 06:53 PM.
Reason: Added link