That has to be the worst "proof" that atheism is wrong that I have ever seen. That said, the site in the OP link is obviously an atheist website. There is no reference to the original post, so is this legit or is it a mock theist claim?
I have seen the peanut butter argument before. That is pretty bad also and is legit so I am not arguing that there are no moronic theists. Just curious about the OP post.