people wont want to sin in heaven obv

why

When in heaven, one has what scripture calls an "incorruptible" nature, which seems to imply an incapacity to sin, which really means the lack of an intent to go against God. We already knew there can be no sin in heaven anyway, because the will of God is always done there (unlike on earth where man's will often prevails). You could say God's and man's wills are in accord in heaven, not to say they are identical any more than God's and Adam's wills were identical when Adam was "perfect" before corrupting himself.

So it was 50/50 right? Either Adam sinned or he didn't. Well, suppose Adam chose not to sin. Do you think he would have sinned later on in his life? No? Okay, suppose Adam never sinned ever. Suppose Eve never sinned ever. What about their children? And their grandchildren? And so on…

What are the odds that no one before us (here in 2011) ever sinned? Practically ZERO percent, right? So why do you act like evil exists because of Adam’s 50/50 choice instead of preaching the reality: God’s world will 99.99...% result in evil.

And yet you say God is good.

That is what i was going to ask but there is never a good answer. It was an inevitable trap as far as i can see.

That isn't what 50/50 means.

This involves a lot of random speculation without Biblical foundation. No one knows what the probabilities were. No one knows what would have happened if Adam hadn't chosen to sin when he did. Maybe the tree was only going to be there for a limited time. Maybe Adam was the only one in jeopardy. Etc.

If Adam's will was "perfect" then how did he corrupt himself? How could he have gone against god and eat the apple?

So in heaven everyone will follow GOD and no one will even have an argument and debate with him about things? Everyone will be a robot? Great times! Mindless zombies

Maybe the Bible is a fairy tale. And maybe Zeus was the real God, but we all missed the boat. And maybe God doesn't care about us either way. And maybe there is no God.

You're right, no one knows what the probabilities are.

Concerto, so if a person gets to heaven but he disagrees with god about the way he has abandoned people on earth will he/she just change their mind and agree with god that he has done a good job since in heaven everyone seems to just worship god as if everything he does is perfect ? For example, what if I become a believer and get to heaven and when I meet god I will tell him, hey god I completely object to the way you have abandoned of all these hungry children in Africa I also think that you have not been doing a good job when it comes to designing earth. All those natural disasters, diseases, etthiNly have pretty much abandoned humanity yet you are asking for unconditional love and worship which seems very not cool. So how is that going to work out?

u are all being trolled by the master troll Concerto, its obvious

You're describing a paradox. Paradoxes can't exist. Like God.

As you said, responsibility is intent. It has nothing to do with "duty", because no-one has a duty to do anything.

Under the auspices of an omnipotent being, nothing could possibly happen unless it was intended by him. Responsibilty automatically falls on any observer with the power to change a foreseeable outcome.

If a child is certainly about to be hit by a car and you know you can certainly save her by calling out, you are completely responsible for her death if you stand silent and watch, because you had the power to prevent it.

Because you had the power to prevent it, if you had *intended* her not to die, you would have called out.

If you (or a god) have the same infallible foresight and power with regards to everything in reality, you (or a god) are completely responsible for everything in reality.

Bump.

Ditto.